Comparison

Dungeon Logbook vs Backloggd

Backloggd is the largest social game journal on the web — a Letterboxd-style platform with reviews, lists, and a huge community. Dungeon Logbook is a smaller, opinionated alternative built for RPG, Soulslike, and CRPG fans who care about how their tools feel. This page is an honest comparison; we'll tell you when Backloggd is the better choice.

At a glance

FeatureDungeon LogbookBackloggd
PriceFree forever, written in our docsFree, Patreon-funded
IdentityDark-fantasy interface built for RPG fansGeneric Letterboxd-style web UI
FocusPersonal journal + character sheetSocial reviews + lists + ratings
Community sizeSmall, growingLarge, established
Public profileAuto-generated character sheet with class, titles, sigilStandard activity feed and lists
Cross-platform trackingPC, console, handheld, tabletop — one libraryPC, console, handheld
Open about monetizationAffiliate + donations, no subscriptions ever (public commitment)Patreon, no paywalled features

Identity is the biggest difference

Backloggd looks like every other modern web app — clean, light, generic. Dungeon Logbook is a deliberate dark-fantasy product. Diablo 2-inspired panels. Rarity-colored game ratings. AvQest title typography. A 'character sheet' profile with auto-derived class titles like 'The Completionist' or 'The Hoarder'. If you're an RPG, Souls, or CRPG fan who picks tools by taste — Bear over Notes, Arc over Chrome, Linear over Jira — that's the lane we're in. If you don't care about aesthetic, Backloggd is the bigger network and serves you better.

Journal vs review aggregator

Backloggd has invested heavily in the social review layer: ratings, scores, lists, follows, feeds. It's a great place to read what other people think of a game. Dungeon Logbook puts the personal journal first. Your library is your story — your timeline of finished campaigns, dropped quests, and the long backlog. Reviews and ratings exist but they're for you, not for a public feed.

Free-forever, written down

Both apps are currently free. The structural difference is what's promised: we've publicly committed that the social and communication layer will never be paywalled, because gating those features defeats the point. Our monetization plan is donations plus affiliate links on game cards. The social baseline stays free, full stop.

Cross-platform and tabletop

Both track PC, console, and handheld games. We also support tabletop games in the same library because most RPG players have one foot in each world. If you keep your D&D campaign separate from your Elden Ring backlog, that won't matter; if you'd rather see them in one tome, we do that.

When Backloggd is the better choice

Use Backloggd if you want the largest active community, are deep into reading and writing reviews, want to follow other curators and discover games socially, or simply don't care about the visual aesthetic of your tracker. Their network effect is real and we won't pretend otherwise.

Visit Backloggd

Questions

Common questions about Backloggd

Is Dungeon Logbook a Backloggd clone?

No. We share the core 'log your games' concept the way any tracker does, but the audience, aesthetic, and product focus are different. Backloggd is a generalist social-first review platform; Dungeon Logbook is a personal journal for RPG-focused players who want the tool to feel like part of their hobby, not just a database.

Can I import my Backloggd library?

Not yet. CSV import is on the roadmap. For now, you can re-add games via our RAWG-powered search — most titles are one click.

Why would I switch if Backloggd has more users?

You probably wouldn't, unless the aesthetic and free-forever positioning matters to you. Many users keep both — Backloggd for social discovery, Dungeon Logbook as their personal tome.

Will Dungeon Logbook ever add reviews and follows?

Possibly — a lightweight version, focused on RPG/Souls/CRPG discussions rather than a global feed. Whatever ships, the free-forever rule applies.

Begin your tome.

Free, forever. Your library, your way.

Start Your Quest

No card required. No paywall. Ever.

Made for the patient gamer.

Dungeon Logbook